Thursday, September 24, 2026

What Shame Does to Trust

 

What Shame Does to Trust

On sexual abuse, self-respect, and the experience of being met as a human being

Many years ago, I sat with twenty-six hours of conversations before me. Nineteen women and men had shared experiences related to the sexual abuse of children. Some had themselves been subjected to abuse. Some were parents. Others worked at a Norwegian incest centre. The conversations were recorded, transcribed, and eventually amounted to 633 pages of text. The material first formed part of my doctoral research and was later developed into a book chapter published in 2012.

At the time, I was trying to understand what they were telling me about shame.

Reading the material again today, I see more clearly that the conversations were also about something else. They were about trust—about what may happen when the person who was supposed to protect becomes the person who violates, and when closeness becomes associated with danger.

Sexual abuse violates the body, but the violation does not end at the boundaries of the body. It may also affect a person’s relationship with others and with themselves. In the conversations, loss of self-respect, difficulties in setting boundaries, and diminished trust in others were closely intertwined with shame. One participant described how repeated experiences of violated trust could eventually lead to a point where one no longer trusted anyone.

The nineteen participants were, of course, not representative of everyone who has experienced sexual abuse. The study was confined to one cultural and institutional context, and the participants were selected from among people who had already spent considerable time working through their experiences and were considered able to take part in such conversations.

Yet certain experiences emerged from what they told me that continue to challenge me.

Gradually, the question became less about what had happened to them and more about what needed to be allowed to happen afterwards.

The Shame That Hides

Shame has a peculiar quality. It can make a person want to be seen and to disappear at the same time.

Someone who feels shame may long to be understood while simultaneously fearing the moment when another person truly sees them. Shame draws the person towards silence: Do not tell. Do not show this. If others knew who you really were, they would turn away.

In the interviews, staff members spoke about people who arrived at the centre hardly daring to take up space. Some spoke very little. They could be afraid of being a burden, afraid to ask questions, afraid of doing something wrong. One staff member explained that they therefore never initiated conversations about the abuse. The person who came to the centre had to decide whether and when the words would come. Some simply sat on the sofa, trying to find a sense of safety.

At first glance, very little may appear to happen when a person is allowed to sit on a sofa without being required to speak. Yet for someone who has previously experienced others crossing the boundaries of their body and their life, this may itself constitute a new experience: no one demands access. No one takes control.

I decide.

Respect Before Treatment

One of the clearest themes in the material was respect. Participants spoke both about being respected by others and about gradually developing respect for themselves. One woman simply wanted to be respected for who she was, to be seen and accepted. One man questioned what significance his house, car, and other material possessions really had for his sense of self. What mattered was self-respect.

It sounds self-evident. Human beings should be treated with respect. Yet the word becomes more demanding when we ask what respect actually entails within a helping relationship.

It becomes visible in concrete practices: whether we listen before interpreting, whether we can tolerate silence, whether we allow another person to retain ownership of their own story, and whether we accept that a person may say no even to something we believe would help.

Here the material touches upon a fundamental question in social work and therapy: Who is the expert on a person’s life?

The professional may possess knowledge the other person does not. She may know the research, methods of treatment, and possible consequences of traumatic experiences. But she does not know the other person’s life from within.

One staff member at the centre expressed this in a way that has remained with me. She said that the people who used the centre had to be regarded as the experts on their own lives. Only the person seeking help could determine what worked and what did not. The task of the helper was to try to discover possibilities together with the other person.

It is a simple idea with far-reaching consequences.

From Object to Subject

I return to the image of the person sitting on the sofa and being allowed to remain silent.

No story is demanded. No explanation is forced. The other person retains the right to open or close the door to their own life.

When I analysed the material, I found a language for this in Martin Buber.

Buber distinguishes between I–It and I–Thou. In an I–It relationship, the other becomes something I observe, investigate, use, or attempt to change. Such objectifying knowledge is often necessary. A doctor must be able to examine the body. A researcher must analyse material. A social worker must sometimes assess risk.

The difficulty arises when the person becomes identical with what we know about them.

In the book chapter, I described the dialogical relationship as an encounter between subjects, in which the other person is not merely the object of my actions but someone who genuinely stands before me. I also wrote about the freedom that may lie in once again experiencing oneself as a subject in the presence of another rather than remaining the object others have previously made one into.

For people who have experienced sexual abuse, this distinction assumes particular significance. Abuse entails the disregard of another person’s body, will, and boundaries. A human being is treated as though they do not fully belong to themselves.

Help must therefore also make room for experiences that move in the opposite direction: someone listens; a boundary is respected; the person decides what to disclose; and the right to stay or leave remains their own.

The relationship itself thereby becomes part of the help.

New Experiences

When I read the interviews today, one thing in particular strikes me: how strongly the participants emphasised experience rather than explanation.

One staff member recalled that they had previously spent considerable time talking with users about their problems, about the abuse, and about everything that had gone wrong. In her experience, such conversations did not necessarily bring about change. What mattered was identifying situations in which shame did not exercise the same power and building upon these small experiences.

This points towards something fundamental. A person who has lost trust cannot easily be argued back into trust.

We can explain that the world also contains people with good intentions. We can say that the danger is no longer the same. We can assure someone that they have value. But trust does not arise as the conclusion of an argument.

It grows when someone keeps their word, stops when a boundary has been reached, listens without taking over, and remains without demanding something in return.

Gradually, the world may begin to look different.

Belonging

Another of the seven categories that emerged from the analysis was inclusion.

Some of those who came to the centre discovered that they were not alone. They encountered people who recognised feelings and thoughts they themselves had understood as private defects. One staff member described how users could arrive deeply withdrawn and afraid, but gradually come to recognise others with similar thoughts and emotions. She believed that this could allow them to begin to imagine a future.

Shame isolates. It can lead a person to believe that they are different in a way that makes community dangerous.

When an experience is shared with others, something may shift. What had previously been understood as a characteristic of the person—there is something wrong with me—may gradually come to be understood as a response to something that was done to them.

Responsibility can be placed where it belongs without the experience itself disappearing. A person may continue to carry wounds from abuse without also carrying the perpetrator’s guilt.

Emotions That Were Not Allowed

The material also revealed how difficult it could be to allow one’s own emotions to exist. A person could love someone and at the same time despise what that person had done. Grief, anger, fear, and guilt could coexist. Some experienced shame after speaking about the abuse, as though disclosure itself constituted a betrayal of the family or even of the perpetrator.

One woman spoke about crying.

She explained that people could weep for the loss of something they had never had. A safe childhood, perhaps. A parent who should have protected them. The right to be a child.

Then she said something that has stayed with me: for some people, it had been dangerous to cry.

The consequences could have been severe. They still carried that experience with them.

Tears, too, may therefore have to be experienced anew. The body must discover that crying is no longer followed by punishment.

Emotions need a place where they can exist without having to justify themselves.

Seven Words

When I analysed the conversations, I initially organised the material into approximately seventy themes and subsequently brought these together into seven main areas: respect, inclusion, positive self-evaluation, recognition, disclosure of emotions, treating oneself and others as subjects, and new experiences that could increase trust in others. The analysis was explicitly interpretive. The categories were not intended to represent an objective reality simply discovered by the researcher; they emerged through the encounter between the material, the participants, and the researcher’s interpretation.

At the time, I called them categories.

Reading them again many years later, the word seems almost too technical. They also describe something both simpler and more difficult: the conditions that may allow a person once again to live among others without constantly having to protect themselves from them.

When I worked with the material and later wrote the book chapter in 2012, I read these conversations through a language of risk, professional expert systems, and trust. The volume in which the chapter appeared was itself concerned with risk, and I drew, among others, on Ulrich Beck and Anthony Giddens to understand how people relate to professional helping systems in a society characterised by uncertainty.

I coded, sorted, and attempted to formulate categories that could describe what the participants were telling me. That was the researcher’s task.

Today, I read the same pages more slowly. It is not the risk society that I notice first.

I notice the sofa. The silence. The person who is allowed to sit without being questioned. The tears that were once dangerous. The small experience of discovering that a no is actually heard.

Professional helping practices require knowledge, methods, and concepts. Yet these old conversations remind me of something that precedes all of them: the encounter with another human being.

A person who has been violated may have learned that closeness is dangerous, that words can be used against them, and that trust leads to betrayal. Trust cannot then be demanded as the price of admission to help.

It must be allowed to grow through experience.

What was damaged within a relationship cannot be repaired by words alone. Yet in encounters with other people, something new may slowly become possible.

Not that what happened disappears.

But that it no longer has to determine the whole world.

Reference

Pettersen, K. T. (2012). Strategies for coping with health risks in the aftermath of childhood sexual abuse within the context of a Norwegian incest center. In K. P. Knutsen, S. Kvam, P. Langemeyer, A. Parianou, & K. Solfield (Eds.), Narratives of risk: Narrative des Risikos: Interdisciplinary studies / Interdisziplinäre Beiträge (pp. 465–481). Waxmann.


What was damaged within a relationship cannot be repaired by words alone. 

Yet in encounters with other people, something new may slowly become possible.


This essay was written in a conversation with Claude/Anthropic and OpenAI/ChatGPT

No comments:

Post a Comment