The One Who Walks Beside Me
I have always had imaginary friends. One of them is my own shadow. On the Meseta, on my way to Santiago, I used to see it ahead of me. The morning sun stretched my legs far across the gravel, and my pack became a hump that made me laugh. One day a cloud passed in front of the sun. My shadow disappeared, and I found I missed it. When it returned, I greeted it.
“There you are.”
I knew perfectly well what had brought it back. Even so, it was a you I greeted. There is something comic about that, and something familiar and dear. When I later wrote about the walk in “Together with My Shadow,” chapter 7 of The Way That Found Me, I was trying to get at that sense of familiarity. Now, as I read Paige E. Davis’s The Imagination Scientist, I wonder what we practise when we make room for someone in a conversation conducted in our own voice.
On the road I could finish speaking and hear what I had actually said. Sometimes my words surprised me. I have needed that same attentiveness in conversations with other people, especially when I already think I know what they are going to say. It is easy then to hear an answer that fits the conversation I have already had in my head.
Among the Rose Bushes
In her review of the book in Nature, Josie Glausiusz tells of two imaginary friends she had as a child. They lived among the rose bushes in the garden and were called Boy and Girl. They argued all the time, and Glausiusz always won. She cheerfully puts this down to her superior knowledge of everything a three-year-old could possibly know. The rose bushes must have been a pleasant place to argue for the person who got to write everyone’s lines.
Her brother had a companion called Embley. He appeared when her brother was small and kept him company when whooping cough kept him home for several weeks. As an adult, her brother remembered little about what Embley looked like. What he remembered was that Embley was always available. That is a lovely detail to be left with. When you tell someone about a friend, they often ask what the friend was like. Perhaps the most exact answer here is that he was there when the boy had time on his hands and the others were at school.
Davis is particularly interested in the child’s ability to imagine that the companion has a mind of its own. A child can give an invisible friend or a teddy bear wishes and opinions and respond to them in play. The friend can want something different, disagree, or be a nuisance. Davis also tells us about imaginary twins who invented an imaginary friend of their own. How much company does one need, exactly? Before long, there might have been a full table, even with only one chair.
The fun in these stories matters. It would be easy for me to talk about play as an exercise in social understanding and make it sound as though the children were sitting among the rose bushes preparing for the world of work. The girl who invented the twins evidently had something more interesting to do. She gave her invented figures imaginations that carried on from where her own had begun. She could still decide what they came up with. Yet part of the fun was that they came up with it.
Glausiusz also describes studies in which children with imaginary friends, as a group, score higher on some measures of social understanding and communication. There can be several explanations for an association like that. What I recognise in Davis’s suggestion is the shift that takes place in play. The child makes up an answer they could have given themselves and gives it to someone who has reasons of their own for answering that way. That little shift makes room for a question. What does this look like from over there?
My shadow was a simpler figure than Boy or Girl. It had no opinion about how far we should walk. Still, it was so conspicuous ahead of me that it was easy to speak to. The first time I spoke to it on the journey, I was on the old Roman road beyond Puente la Reina. I had been walking alone for hours. I remember how funny the shadow looked and how I laughed. I have forgotten what I said. Anyone who happened to hear me would have had little to report. For me, it was the beginning of a companionship that would last for many stages of the journey.
A Voice on the Gravel Road
Between Los Arcos and Viana, I asked why I was there. I could explain how I had got there. My doctoral work on shame and sexual abuse had left its mark, and I needed some distance before defending my thesis. I had planned the journey for months. I could have told all this to whoever sat beside me on the plane. Out on the gravel road, with the sun warming my neck and every small stone registering underfoot, I heard myself still asking.
Asking what prompted me to book a journey is different from asking what I am going to do with the time I have given myself. I can answer the first question by telling what happened before I left. The second stays with me after the explanation is over. I think that is why the explanation sounded so tidy when I said it aloud. It suited the person who had planned the journey at home. Right then, I was also someone who had to decide whether to stop by the roadside for a drink.
I began singing the song about the hundred bottles of beer on the wall. I had carried it with me since my childhood in the United States. I had sung it when lessons dragged on, on the school bus, and at night when I wanted to fall asleep. The rule is simple. Each verse leaves you with one bottle fewer. If you start at a hundred, you have given yourself something to do for quite a while. By the time I reached the last bottle, half an hour had passed. My shadow had come along the whole way.
I could have spent that half-hour looking for a better answer to why I was walking. Instead, childhood came closer through a song I knew well enough to keep going without thinking. I was surprised how easily my voice found its way back to it. At school the child had used the song to get through a long day. On the pilgrimage the adult was doing much the same. Both had more time than they quite knew what to do with.
A sound can hold more of a life than I might manage to tell if I sat down to describe myself. If someone had asked what I was taking to Spain from my childhood, I would hardly have mentioned that song. There were times on the road when words I had learned from books were the first I reached for. The song came of its own accord. It came with the school bus and the evenings when I was trying to sleep, and it made half an hour on a gravel road into something I still remember.
Being Allowed to Finish
On the Meseta I could walk for hours without seeing anyone. I had chosen to walk alone. That gave me the freedom to stop when I wanted and decide how far to go according to how my body felt. I value that kind of freedom. But there could come a point when I would have been glad to see someone in the distance. The landscape changed so slowly that I could walk for a long time and still feel as though I were standing still. There was scarcely a bend to look forward to.
By then my shadow had become a familiar presence. I saw it stop when I stopped. When I sat down for a drink, it fell somewhere beside me. The pack was mine to carry, but its weight took on a comic outline on the ground. When the cloud took my shadow away, I became aware of how often I had looked for it. I felt a small absence in a landscape that otherwise looked as it had before.
I think that was why the greeting came so naturally. It is natural to say hello when you finally catch sight of someone familiar you have been looking for. On a road like that, a few words can change what it feels like to be alone. Anyone watching from a distance would have seen one man with a pack and a walking stick. From where I stood, I had just got my company back.
At a table with other people, I sometimes keep going with an explanation because the person across from me nods. Perhaps she is simply showing that she is listening. Even so, the nod can be enough for me to stop listening to my own words. On the road, no one nodded. I could hear how hard I was trying to sound convincing, even when it was unclear whom I meant to convince. Sometimes that was enough to make me laugh. Other times I heard a note of unease that had been easier to overlook while it was still in my head.
You can be wonderfully eloquent in your thoughts. A sentence can change direction halfway through and no one need notice. An objection can slip by so quickly that you barely get a chance to raise it. When I said the sentence aloud, the words lay there in the order I had actually put them. I could hear myself contradict something I had said only moments before. With time to spare on the road, I could let both statements stand for a while. Perhaps there was a reason for each.
In the evenings I ate with other pilgrims. We told one another where we came from, how far we had walked, and what we had seen. It was good to hear other voices after a long day. People asked about things I had passed over in the telling. Sometimes I also found that something from the day was hard to put into words at the table. On the road I had had time to wait for the words. At dinner the next story would begin, and I wanted to hear it. The two kinds of company had rhythms of their own.
There was also something I missed in the figure on the ground. At home I was used to people knowing me from one part of my life or another. At a pilgrim hostel, a stranger might ask how my feet were before asking who I was back home. It was a pleasant order in which to be asked. At the same time, I sometimes missed being with someone who knew more of the story. On the road, childhood came with me in the song, and my work came with me in the questions I asked. It was my life that had come to Spain with me, even when all that could be seen was a walking stick, a hat, and a pack. Perhaps that was why it felt so strange to see the whole outline disappear when the cloud came over.
The One Who Knows the Way
On the way to Reliegos, I walked almost straight ahead for nearly three hours. Grain, road, and sky. The photographs I took began to look alike, and at some point I found myself waiting for the landscape to do something. My thoughts went round in circles. Finally, I told my shadow that we needed to pull ourselves together.
We was a useful word just then. I could tell off two walkers while knowing that only one of us could do anything about it. I lifted my head. Later I saw a farmer walking ahead of a flock of sheep. He walked briskly, and they followed without a dog to drive them. I began to think about all the times people follow whoever is out in front simply because that person is already there. I laughed.
The shadow also goes out in front when the sun is behind me. Out there it could look quite purposeful. The walking stick stretched across the road, the legs were long, and the figure kept pace with me. It had all the outward signs of someone who was going somewhere. I could ask where we were going and answer Santiago on its behalf. But to find out where the road actually went, I had to look for the yellow arrows. My shadow would have followed every step down the wrong road, too.
From time to time I thought of Heidegger’s expression being-in-the-world. On the high plain I could try it out against something quite ordinary. A yellow arrow mattered because I was going somewhere and because taking a wrong turn would cost me time and effort. A stone was part of the road until I nearly tripped over it. Then it was something I had to watch for as I took my next step. The idea took on the scale it needed then and there. I had to watch where I put my foot.
The inward conversation needed that same movement out towards the world. I could talk my way to a sense of where I was heading. An arrow at a junction could still make me change direction. In the same way, a conversation over dinner could bring something into view that I had missed during the day. I had taken my own steps and heard my own words. What I heard at the table came from someone whose day on foot had been different, even when the road was the same.
Letting the Other Person Answer
In social work I have often needed to imagine what it might be like to sit on the other side of the table. I need that ability as soon as I start thinking about how to ask the first question. What might someone fear will happen if they answer? What words would I use carefully if it were my life we were talking about? Questions like these can help me slow down. They can also make me quicker to believe I have understood.
Imagine a conversation about three appointments a woman has missed. Before we meet, I might have rehearsed how to bring it up without blaming her. I might imagine that she was anxious about coming and say that I understand it can be difficult to attend. Perhaps she tells me that she went to the address at the top of the letter. That was where she had been the last time. I had come into the conversation with several possible explanations for why she had stayed away. She had turned up somewhere else.
An answer like that calls for something quite concrete. I need to find the letter and look at how it is written. Reading it with her, I may discover that the address she used is clearly printed at the top, while the one she was meant to go to is mentioned in passing. Now I can see why she went there. I can also see why my first remark about how difficult it can be to attend might have sounded strange. She had made the effort to come.
I could have imagined this possibility before we spoke. That would have been good preparation. But there is something particular about hearing someone answer a question I barely knew I was asking. I may have to revise my own account while we are still sitting there. And if I write a note afterwards, I can record where she turned up and how we discovered the misunderstanding. That way what she told me can matter to the next person who speaks with her.
Davis writes about the child’s ability to give an imaginary friend a mind of its own. I am struck by how close this is to a skill we use throughout our lives. We run through a conversation before it happens. We let an absent person raise the objection we expect to hear. Sometimes that is the only way we spot a weakness in what we plan to say. And when the other person finally sits down in front of us, we can bring that same attentiveness to hearing how she differs from the version of her we have already spoken with.
This is a matter of practical judgement. I can use my imagination to find a question that gives the other person a little more room. I find out how much room there really is once she answers. Do I have time to follow up on what she said? Can what she tells me change what I came to do? The way I listen and act after hearing her answer is where the inward rehearsal is put to the test.
Onwards
I have always had imaginary friends. My shadow is the one I notice most because it can turn up while I am busy with something else entirely. I only have to turn so the light falls behind me. Then there it is, often in a shape that makes me think it has had more fun with my body than I have had all day.
On the Meseta it was good company. I could ask why I had come and spend the rest of the stage letting the question follow my steps. I could sing the old song and hear how much of childhood could be carried in a few words. And when I stopped, I often found myself thinking how good it felt to put down the pack. A thought like that needs a body that has carried one for a while.
In “Together with My Shadow,” I wrote, “The shadow walked with me, but it could not walk for me.” There was a small stone from the garden in my pocket. I could feel it through the cloth. My shadow lay in plain sight on the road, from my hat to my walking stick, while the stone stayed where only I knew about it. If someone had asked what I was carrying, I could have put my hand in my pocket and shown them. I could also have waited until we knew each other a little better. That was up to me.
My shadow was just as faithful when I took a wrong turn. To find the next yellow arrow, I had to look up. As soon as I walked on, my shadow was with me again.
References
Davis, P. E. (2026). The imagination scientist: Researching pretend beings and their creators. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/9780198894902.001.0001
Glausiusz, J. (2026). The psychology of imaginary friends — and why they are good for kids. Nature, 659, 587–588. https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-026-03713-9
Pettersen, K. T. (2026, September 1). Chapter 7 Together with My Shadow. Praktisk Filosofi – Practical Philosophy. https://kaaretorgnypettersen.blogspot.com/2026/09/chapter-7-together-with-my-shadow.html
My essay was written in a conversation with ChatGPT



