When Saying No Comes at a Cost
On economic abuse and practical judgment
A woman places an unpaid electricity bill on the table in a social worker’s office. The social worker asks whether they should go through the budget together. The woman has already done the sums. She knows what the electricity costs, how much came into the account, and how much is missing. There is one more thing she is trying to work out.
“If I pay it today, I’ll have to explain myself when I get home.”
Paying the bill herself would be a quiet way of saying no to the demand that she account for what she spends. The bill is still on the table between them. The question has changed.
Economic abuse is a form of domestic abuse that receives too little attention. One reason may be how easily its effects can be described in terms we already use. A bill is unpaid. An account is overdrawn. A repayment agreement has been broken. All three statements may be accurate. Yet they can give a misleading picture of who has been able to make decisions. Economic abuse makes ordinary actions depend on someone else’s permission, and that dependence can persist long after a relationship ends. The practical task is to see where a person’s room for action has narrowed and help them regain a greater say in their own life.
What the Bank Can See
In a study published in Nature, Anna Trendl and colleagues examined anonymised records from a major British bank. They traced the banking histories of 5,428 women who had told the bank they had experienced financial abuse and compared them with those of 15,602 customers with no known disclosure of such abuse. The groups were matched on demographic and socioeconomic characteristics at the start of the period, seven years before the women disclosed the abuse to the bank. Even at that point, there were differences in account balances and signs of financial difficulty. Over time, the researchers found that the women who disclosed abuse had dwindling savings and growing debts, followed by more missed payments and lower credit scores.
The date of disclosure gave the researchers a point of reference. They knew little about when the abuse began. The study draws on records from a single bank, and the comparison cannot establish what caused the differences. The most revealing comparison came when the researchers selected a new control group of women facing similar financial difficulties who had no known disclosure of abuse. The differences in spending on dental care and taxis narrowed, and the researchers found no clear difference in spending on opticians or petrol. The groups still differed in their receipt of benefits, cash withdrawals, changes to account access, and how they contacted the bank. The women who had disclosed abuse used online banking less and were more likely to call or visit a branch.
A low balance tells us there is little money left. That can be true of women in either group. Changing a password or phoning the bank may be an attempt to regain control, but the records tell us little about why a particular woman acted as she did. That is why it matters who gets a chance to tell what happened.
The authors distinguish between financial and economic abuse. Financial abuse concerns money, accounts, and debt. Economic abuse also encompasses the conditions that allow someone to get by, such as being able to work, find somewhere to live, or get where they need to go. A partner who repeatedly makes it difficult for the other person to get to work can undermine their ability to support themselves without making a single transaction. When wages stop coming in, the bank can see that less money is being deposited. What happened before the working day began has to come to light some other way.
What Does It Cost to Say No?
In many relationships, one person takes care of the bills. That can work well. One question tells us more about how the arrangement works than knowing who usually pays. What happens when the other person wants to do something differently? Can she ask to see the accounts, spend money on something she has chosen, or suggest changing the arrangement? Does she have to reckon with threats, humiliation, or losing access to money if she says no?
A bank statement can show whose name is on the account. Whether the woman named as the account holder has control depends on what she can actually do with the money and what happens when she does. Buying a bus ticket may seem straightforward to someone who sees the amount on the statement. For the woman who will have to explain where she has been when she gets home, the purchase involves a different calculation. She may have good reasons to stay put, even if she would like to go. What she does to get through the day can look like passivity from the outside.
In Book III of the Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle connects deliberation with what is in our power to do. The woman at the table is weighing whether to pay the electricity bill today. She may be able to make the payment, but she has no say over how her partner will react. Waiting can be a considered decision when every option available to her comes at a cost. The abuse narrows the choices she has.
In Book VI, Aristotle connects phronesis, understood here as practical judgment, with the ability to discern what matters in a particular situation. That is what happens when the question at the table changes. The social worker hears that a payment that looks straightforward on the budget can have consequences at home. The form of help needs to be reconsidered. What can they do about the unpaid bill, and how can they do it in a way that gives the woman more control? The answer depends in part on what she herself judges to be possible and safe.
What Remains on the Record
In social work, encounters like this often live on in the case record. Imagine a note that reads, “Repeated difficulties making payments. Wishes to wait.” The next reader will understand that the bill needs attention and may come away thinking the woman is declining help. What she tried to say about the consequences of paying has disappeared.
Now imagine a note that reads, “She says her partner demands an explanation when she spends money from the account. She is concerned about how her partner will react if she pays the electricity bill today. She would like to discuss possible options at a follow-up meeting.” Where it is appropriate and safe to record these details, wording like this gives the next reader a better basis for continuing the conversation. It preserves the woman’s own account and shows what she wants help with.
For the bank, the finding about phone calls and branch visits has a practical implication. When a customer calls about a missed payment, the bank has an opportunity to ask what made it difficult to pay. The answer may have to do with who has access to the account or who will find out that she called. How the bank follows up then becomes part of the help it can offer.
Leaving a relationship can change who has access to the account. The debt can still follow her. The study documents how debt can mount and credit scores can fall in the years leading up to disclosure. These findings tell us little about how long the effects last after a separation. But the implications of debt are easy to see when she is trying to set up a home again. A deposit is due while the repayments are still coming out. Regaining control can therefore involve working out what financial obligations she has and what it will take for her to afford somewhere to live.
Back at the table, the electricity bill is still there. The social worker asks when they can speak again and whether it is safe to call.
“Thursday,” the woman says. “I can call you then.”
The social worker opens the calendar. The woman chooses the time.
References
Aristotle. (1999). Nicomachean ethics (T. Irwin, Trans., 2nd ed.). Hackett Publishing. (See especially Book III, Chapter 3, and Book VI.)
Trendl, A., Sharp-Jeffs, N., Perrier, K., Rodrick, J., Gathergood, J., & Leake, D. (2026). Banking records reveal characteristics of financial abuse. Nature, 658, 1200–1207. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11049-7

No comments:
Post a Comment